Two findings, two different documents
One study cut the instructions and lost nothing. The other let the record build up in detail and gained. They are not in conflict, because they changed different things.
Instructions: cut them
Share of one AI tool's standing instructions removed
Measured on the maker's own coding tests, for one generation of models. Not a public benchmark, and not tested on other kinds of work.
The record: let it build up
Improvement over the strongest existing methods
Achieved with a modest, freely available model, and by the whole method rather than by length alone. Peer reviewed, accepted to ICLR 2026.
Sources: Anthropic, "The new rules of context engineering for Claude 5 generation models", 24 July 2026. "Agentic Context Engineering", Stanford, SambaNova and UC Berkeley, arXiv:2510.04618, ICLR 2026.